- rosalielochner
- Jun 18
- 3 min read
The hill that I am willing to die on is that shortcake should be simple but not sweet. Good shortcake is very much like a craggy vanilla biscuit. What led me to decide to share this recipe is that I was reading the most recent "Kitchen Project" and was annoyed at how much sugar Bronwen Wyatt used in her recipe. So, I went and looked at the recipes on NYT App and they were super sugary too! Then, I went by back to my OG Joy of Cooking and here I saw the sweet/unsweetened split. Joy of Cooking offers two versions of shortcake: one barely sweetened based on biscuits and the second based on sweet American scones.
American's need to reign in all that sugar. Strawberries and whipped cream are plenty sweet on their own. Let's bring back a more subtle and homey tasting shortcake that's equally good with strawberries and vanilla whipped cream as it is the next morning with runny friend eggs.
What makes this recipe different from a simple biscuit recipe (and the one in Joy of Cooking) is the hint of vanilla and the sugary top. That's it. It's super simple and will soak up all the whipped cream and strawberries that you can heap on it.

I've been making a version of this recipe since I got it from our neighbor Joanne back in high school. I remember going to her house to ask for the recipe and Joanne didn't laugh when I confused shortcake and shortbread. This is a tweaked version of her recipe. It's been a spring staple for years.
NOTE ABOUT OPTIONAL ADDED SUGAR: Even though I just railed against overly sweet cake in the paragraphs above, I do like to add 1 tablespoon of sugar to the dough and sprinkle an additional tablespoon of sugar on top of my shortcake. I find that the one tablespoon of elevates the flavors without making the dough sweet. Do feel free to omit it if you prefer to go sugar free. This single tablespoon is nothing compared to the 1/3-1/2 cup of sugar in sweeter recipes. Furthermore I love adding a tablespoon of Turbano sugar on top of the short cake. It's going to give extra texture and (along with the vanilla extra) signal to people that they're eating a dessert and not a health food. You can, of course, omit it if you so choose, but I highly recommend it.
NOTE ABOUT BISCUIT STYLE PRESENTATION: We have always eaten our strawberry shortcake cut into wedges. You can absolutely use english muffin cutters or even cupcake tins to make biscuit style shortcake. Just make sure to watch your cook time because small cakes will cook in as little as 7-10 minutes.
Classic Strawberry Shortcake
requires one 8 or 9 inch pie or cake pan. Takes 20 minutes to asseble and 15-20 minutes to bake. Serves 8.
Ingredients
2 cups all purpose flour
1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon fine sea salt
1 tablespoon sugar (optional but most American pallets will expect a hint of sweetness)
8 tablespoons cold unsalted butter (good quality but not European style)
1 egg, cold
2/3 cup light cream (or 1/3 cup whole milk and 1/3 cup heavy cream)
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 tablespoon Turbano sugar (optional but highly recommend)
Whipping cream and strawberries to serve.
STEP ONE
Preheat oven to 420 degrees. line a 9 inch or 8 inch cake pan with parchment paper and lightly oil the bottom and sides of the pan. Combine flour, salt, sugar, and baking powder in a mixing bowl. Cut your butter into small chunks and add to your flour mixture. Then use your fingers to smoosh the butter into the flour mixture until butter pieces are intigrated and the size of small peas. Set aside. See first two photos below.
STEP TWO
In a separate bowl mix together your egg, cream, and vanilla. Then add egg-cream mixture to the flour mixture and stir sparingly. The dough will resemble biscuit batter and not fully stick together. Use your fingers to gently spread the dough out on your pan. It's going to be craggy. Sprinkle 1 tablespoon of turbano or other coarse sugar over top. See photos below. Bake for 15-18 minutes for an 8" pan 12-16 minutes for a 9" pan.
Allow Short cake to cool slightly before serving with whipped cream and fresh strawberries. Short cake can also be rewarmed in the oven, but is best eaten within the first 48 hours. My favorite way to eat leftover short cake is to try it in a pan next to some fried eggs. It's almost as good as with strawberries and cream.
